Abernathy wrote: ↑Sun Aug 17, 2025 9:27 pm
Generally speaking, flags are fucked up. They cause nothing but trouble. So does patriotism. Johnson was correct about it being the last refuge of the scoundrel.
I find patriotism/nationalism profoundly distasteful, but primarily completely irrational. “Pride” in your country ? Pride is, generally speaking, a feeling that should relate to say, a personal achievement- a beautiful garden, say, or a scale model of the Taj Mahal constructed entirely out of beer can ringpulls - or that of a loved one. Something you’ve actually done.
The entirely random occurrence of one’s birth having taken place in a particular geographic location isn’t an achievement. You don’t get a say in it, let alone a choice.
It makes zero sense. This may be at least partly why it appeals so readily to fuckwitted simpletons.
Intellectually I agree with you. But politically this is a non-starter, and the Liberal Tim internet response I've seen a lot recently, of 'get over it flag shaggers' is both hackneyed and politically stupid. Constantly ceding ground to the hypocrites who seek to instrumentalise the basic brute fact that patriotism is easy, patriotism is powerful, and patriotism is prevalent.
It's the last refuge of a scoundrel BECAUSE it's so powerful, and gives a get out of jail free card to the cynic. To dismiss it is like dismissing religion. We can't. The morally awkward things don't vanish because we've 'explained' them. It doesn't work. The 'left' or the 'liberals' need to be far better at handling it than they are, and this is not to take anything away from the wilful ignorance and cynicism of the cunts we face. It's all the more important because of them.
Fundamentally, there's something underneath. The expectation of defeat, the expectation of 'oppression', the expectation of some mytho-heroic conflict with 'Them'. People want to articulate a sense of being downtrodden. It gives symbolic, powerful structure to actual economic and social decline, and gives romance where there is only grimness. The flag is the easiest route to it, and it's playing a game entirely on the right's front lawn.
The issue there is, of course, that it's so embedded with the right that playing the game at all is easily readable as playing the same old Reform playground bundle: why ape them when people can just vote for them instead? For all the fear and wailing about cultural marxism et al, the right have been infinitely cleverer with their cultural work in this space.
The idiot formerly known as cycloon. Still an idiot, mind.