- Mon Nov 10, 2025 12:00 pm
#99534
The story has become *massive* on news media and outlets like LBC (and no doubt on GBeebies too, but I'm not fucking going there). An extended rumination on the BBC's impartiality and/or the lack thereof.
The overwhelming impression I'm getting is that the BBC has been the victim of a deliberate and concerted stitch-up, a coup, by the Telegraph and Robbie Gibb, and the malign influences of Tufton Street.
As ever, O'Brien is in the right place. Yes, the edit of Trump's insurrection-inciting speech in January 2021 was a stupid mistake. But it was emphatically not "fake news". Trump said what he said. It was recorded, and Trump was impeached by Congress for it. It cannot have misled many, if any at all, viewers.
The BBC's DG and News chief should have been fighting back, not resigning (though I am gratified to note that Deborah Turness has defended BBC journalists this morning.)
Now, Trump has been given the space further to propagate his lie that he did not incite violent insurrection in an attempt to overturn a legitimate election result.
I do think the repercussions of this are potentially huge. The future of the BBC is at stake, though arguably, it always has been. Is the BBC institutionally biased? I really don't think so. I sometimes detect left-wing bias in the BBC's output, but more often, I detect what seems to me to be right-wing bias. I've often thought that an indicator that broadly speaking, the corporation is getting things right. There is surely no such thing as absolute, pure down the line impartiality - but the BBC makes a pretty good fist of it.
The other thing that this might have brought about and made more urgent is the debate - that was always going to have to be had - about the BBC's future funding model as our national public broadcaster. There is almost consensus that the TV licence fee model is no longer sustainable in a multi-channel, multi-media, streaming 21st century media environment .
We have a Labour government that I hope can add the active defence and preservation of our national broadcaster to the long list of things that need repair. - and get to it.
"The opportunity to serve our country: that is all we ask.” John Smith, May 11, 1994.