User avatar
By The Weeping Angel
#105330
Tubby Isaacs wrote: Wed Feb 04, 2026 3:42 pm FFS

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfr ... ral-system
If Reform ever wins power in Westminster, it will be because of Labour’s cowardice

George Monbiot
Starmer could improve our unfair electoral system to stop the hard right, but he won’t. All the party has left are threats about ‘splitting the vote’
It's not a 'threat". It's a fact. As it was when I voted Green in my constituency in 2024. Was I being threatened by the Greens?

But let's be clear about what this argument is. It's saying that the Government, having at no point mentioned they might change the electoral system, change it explicitly to stop another party from winning? How would that not be seen as a massive stitch up?

Note the typical assumption from this sort of person that everyone agrees with them really. There's virtually no mass pressure to change the voting system. People had a chance to do it in 2011, and said very clearly No Thanks.
People have got to stop thinking that PR is a magic bullet that will stop bad people. If you want PR say it's for reasons of fairness.
User avatar
By Tubby Isaacs
#105340
Yeah, exactly.

There's also a lot of wishful thinking about what PR would produce in terms of policy. Zack Polanski throwing money about which he raises only from "the rich" would seem to be a pretty remote possibility. Or perhaps Zack and Ed Davey "just rejoin FFS" and every thing gets fixed like that.

So perhaps what we have now isn't quite the worst of all conceivable governments.
Labour Government 2024 - ?

I don't think he does; he's not a […]

Keir Starmer

There is precedent for taking in to the FCO former[…]

The Guardian

Hey you can assault police officers and get away[…]

Gorton & Denton By-election.

All parties put rubbish on leaflets, but it's[…]